Nirmala Sitharaman responds to Mamata Banerjee over letter to PM Modi for GST exemption

New Delhi, May 09: Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Sunday ruled out exempting Covid vaccines, medicines and oxygen concentrators from GST, saying such an exemption will make the lifesaving items costlier for consumers as manufacturers will not be able to offset the taxes paid on inputs.

Currently, domestic supplies and commercial imports of vaccines attract a 5 per cent Goods and Services Tax (GST), while COVID drugs and oxygen concentrators attract a 12 per cent levy.

Responding to Mamata Banerjee's letter to PM Modi in a series of 16 tweets, the Union Finance Minister pointed out that the full exemption from Customs duties, including IGST, was already available to all COVID relief material imported by the Indian Red Cross for free distribution in the country.

"If full exemption from GST is given, vaccine manufacturers would not be able to offset their input taxes and would pass them on to the end consumer/citizen by increasing the price," Sitharaman said in a series of tweets.

"A 5 per cent GST rate ensures that the manufacturer is able to utilise ITC and in case of overflow of ITC, claim refund. Hence exemption to the vaccine from GST would be counterproductive without benefiting the consumer."

The tweets, 16 of them in all, were in response to Banerjee''s letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

India is facing the world''s worst outbreak of COVID-19 cases with more than 4 lakh new daily COVID-19 cases being reported over the weekend. More than 2.42 lakh people in India have died from the virus infection.

Public health system is buckling under the weight of surging infections and deaths with several parts of the country reporting a shortage of hospital beds, medical oxygen, medicines and vaccines.

To buttress her point on levy of GST on imported goods, Sitharaman said the Centre and states equally split collections made from levy of Integrated GST (IGST).

Further 41 per cent of the Central GST revenue is devolved to States. So out of a collection of Rs 100, as much as Rs 70.50 is the share of the states.

From the GST collected on vaccines, half is earned by the Centre and the other half by the States. Further, 41 per cent of Centre''s collections also get devolved to the States. So states end up receiving almost 70 per cent of the total revenue collected from vaccines.

"In fact, a nominal 5 per cent GST is in the interest of the domestic manufacturer of vaccines and in the interest of the citizens," Sitharaman said.

Mamata Banerjee earlier in the day wrote to Modi seeking exemption from GST and customs duty any donations of oxygen concentrators, cylinders, cryogenic storage tanks and COVID related drugs from organisations or agencies.

Sitharaman in her tweets mentioned that these items are already exempted from customs duty and health cess. Besides, Integrated GST (IGST) is also exempted on all COVID relief material imported by the Indian Red Cross for free distribution in the country.

Also IGST exemption has been given in case of goods imported free of cost for free distribution in the country by any entity, state government, relief agency or autonomous body on the basis of a certificate issued by a state government.

"In order to augment the availability of these items, the government has also provided full exemption from basic customs duty and health cess to their commercial imports," Sitharaman said.

In a point by point reply to the Finance Minister''s tweets, TMC MP Mahua Moitra demanded all vaccines to be added to the list of items that are exempt from levy of IGST.

To Sitharaman''s point of full exemption from customs duties, including IGST, being already available to all Covid relief material imported by Indian Red Cross for free distribution in the country, Moitra said, "Why does everything have to go through the Red Cross of India. Why only IGST. Why can''t citizens and hospitals buy even domestic goods without GST."

Moitra said duties may have been wavied on Remdesivir injections, but Indians continue to pay Central-GST and State-GST on these lifesaving medicines. "These should be waived."

To the Finance Minister''s point of states getting more than two-third of taxes collected, the TMC MP said the Centre does not have a good track record of giving states their dues.

She went on to say that vaccines and other items should be brought under zero per cent levy to allow producers to offset taxes on inputs. "So if we''re willing to 70.50% of the way - can''t the centre manage 29.50% of the burden?" she asked FM.

Effective May 3, the government exempted IGST on import of COVID-relief material received as donation for free distribution in the country, a move which helped speed up customs clearances of such imports.

This exemption would be subject to nodal authorities, appointed by the state governments, authorising any entity, relief agency or statutory body, for free distribution of such relief material.

The said goods can be imported free of cost by a state government or, any entity/ relief agency/ statutory body, authorized in this regard for free distribution anywhere in India.